Poll: Should we wait til we recieve a tail to post a review?

[AniaR]

Don't know what this thread/poll are about? Please read up on this: http://mernetwork.com/index/showthread.php?1289-Suggestion-for-avoiding-review-drama/page2

This poll is for voting on whether or not you feel a review is only for when someone has received a tail. This would mean someone could NOT post a review if they've been waiting for a while since they have no product to review, but would still be able to post that complaint in the appropriate forum.
OR Perhaps you feel people should be able to write a review when they have yet to receive the tail

Please choose carefully you can only vote once and voting can't be changed later.

Poll will be up for 1 week

EDIT: Can we keep the discussion on the other thread? this is really just intended to be the poll, we've already discussed it quite a bit and it would be great to have all the points in one part instead of having people needing to read two threads.

[OrcaMatt]

Yes BUT...that doesn't mean people shouldn't discuss or update on the process, since this is information people considering buying a tail from somebody would like to know in fairly real-time. Just maybe the review thread for the tail itself isn't the place for that.


If anything separating this sort of 'process' information out of the review will make it more accessible and widely seen.

Edit: Actually the way the proposition is worded I"m not sure if that's a 'yes' or 'no' vote.

[AniaR]

Yes BUT...that doesn't mean people shouldn't discuss or update on the process, since this is information people considering buying a tail from somebody would like to know in fairly real-time. Just maybe the review thread for the tail itself isn't the place for that.

Couldnt fit that all in the poll, that's why it's in the above post here:
This would mean someone could NOT post a review if they've been waiting for a while since they have no product to review, but would still be able to post that complaint in the appropriate forum

Id rather we keep the discussion back and forth on the original thread to keep everything in line and in context and just leave the poll for voting :)

[SweeteSiren]

I'm assuming that shipping problems will be mentioned in another part of the forum? Would it be possible to set up vendor reviews like Yelp?

[AniaR]

I'm assuming that shipping problems will be mentioned in another part of the forum? Would it be possible to set up vendor reviews like Yelp?

Shipping problems would still go in your finished review, but many shipping problems have nothing to do with the tail maker. And yes, one of the admins has been working on a newer reviewing system