Hey Krystal. I know a lot of us are looking for some details to be ironed out before we form a proper conclusion... I guess the questions in my head right now are:
1) Was the part about the discount giving true?
2) The Mertailor claimed that the dorsal fin - the one you weren't happy- was the one you chose because of price range options. (which I completely understand, mermaiding is expensive business!) Is that true?
3) Did you, in fact, also request the free scale top and additional discounted baby tail from the Mertailor?

These might seem like tangential questions, but I just feel like a cohesive answer might help me form a better perspective right now...